...seems too heavy and unatural?
i really don't wanna take off the liquid eyeliner cuz it looks good wat should i do?

if the eyeshadow is really dark, make it lighter definitely. get a thinner liquid eyeliner, avaible in covergirl stuff. not a volumizing mascara, just normal. you should see some improvements or maybe your not cleaning it off right.

use solid eyeliner not as heavy den only put a little bit of eyeshadow on or none andonly put mascara on your top lash the bottom just smearss off

liquid eyeliner. Use a soft khol pencil instead and smudge slightly, much more natural effect but still defines eyes nicely!

put light colors of shadow and no eyeliner or very thin line