Ok.
I've tried multiple black pencils, and all just wear off throughout the day.
I've browsed around a lot and still cannot find one!
It's getting reaallllly annoying, so girls (or guys), got any tips or suggestions in the eyeliner department?

I have no problem with my colored eye pencils, just black.

Thak you.
Thanks everyone.
I've heard MAC a lot, so I'llbe off to try it tomorrow!


*laughs*
Ill give you BEST ANSWER,trumper_player, because you got guts.

Almay has a good one. Last all day.

mac..........ive tried many many kinds but mac worksthe best.. jsut tell them u want a smudgeproof water proof and there u go!! i wont use any other kind now!!! hope it works!!1

I think it really depends on what works with you. But New York Company works very well and also Avon has a really great line of eye liners. It may take some effort to find the right one. Good luck to ya!

u should definitely use a water proof cream liner, they're the most dependable. But if you're still using a pencil like me, i put bare minerals mineral veil (you can use any loose powder) on my eyelid first so the color last all day, doesn't get greasy, or smudge

Try MAC cream eyeliner or just the plain MAC Black eyeliner its works and its fabulous..Or try Chanel they both work great!

Liquid eyeliner is the better for someone who doesn't want to apply touch-ups throughout the day like when wearing eyeliner pencil. Mabeline has the best one.

Thanx Fer The 2 Pts.''

Almay black pearl works amazing lasts all day long and stays vibrant

Ok I know I'm a guy but when my mom talks to her friends and my aunts and stuff they all say some really cheap one for just a couple of bucks its called Wet N' Wild and the dark blue looks black you can buy it at walmart or walgreens heres the link and theres the H20 proof one and its the second link the regular is 99 cents and the h2o proof is $1.99 yeah i know im a guy its called gettin in touch with ur feminine side or w/e lol