I have gym 3 times a week and my eyeliner always smudges!
I don't use liquid eyeliner
I only like to use pencil eyeliner on my bottom lid.
So can you recommend one?
Sorry I meant "What's" lol

Honestly, drugstore eyeliners are just as pricey as eyeliners that can be purchased at sephora.

I bought this sephora brand eyeliner not too long ago for 4 dollars! Some drugestore eyeliners like maybelline can go up to 8 or 9.

The Sephora brand eyeliner is amazing! I really recommend you to trying it.

i'd say you should use waterproof eyeliner.
i have blue eyes so i like to use brown eyeliner because it looks softer. you can also apply eyeliner to your top lid by pulling up your eye lid and applying eyeliner from underneath the lashes rather than on top because it makes your lashes look fuller and more defined.

try loreal hip. i've tried 'em all and there's nothing in a drug store that won't run or smudge. but i hear loreal hip is a really good line. its an imitation of mac and has long lasting staying power. if your willing to spend $13 at macy's, mac's eyeliner is really good. it lasts me a looooong time. i love it.

Jane cosmetics has a great eyeliner, not the pencil kind but the roll-up kind. You always have a fine point, and it is pretty smudge proof, so far as I can tell, and I work out nearly every day.

DONT USE WET AND WILD! it smudges alllll the time. its so annoying.

I use liquid, and it's great! Iwould seriously think about getting some!

spend a little more and get mac
or use one of their shadesticks as liner


just buy one

because the money you spend on drug store doesnt work as well a lot of the times

so its worth it to buy one good item
rather than a lot of useless ones