I currently use Benefit Bad Gal, but am interested in trying DiorShow or Urban Decay's Big Fatty. Can anyone who has tried both Bad Gal and one or both of the others give me a comparison?

Thanks!

i've not tried any of those, i've been a fan of Loreal Voluminous for a million years, and i stand by it loyally. i've tried alot of the more expensive brands, but still i go back to my 8 dollar mascara. go figure.