Well everybody has different types of skin, so I can't tell you for sure that one of those will work. I have tried Pro-Active, and personally I didn't like it. It just didn't mesh well with my skin. But then I have tried neutrogena, and I totally love it. I have heard of Pro-Active helping alot of other people, so just give it a try. And if it doesn't work, then just move on to another product. I know how tiring it can be to have to keep moving from one product to another, but you will find something that goes with your skin!