It really doesn't matter what the odor is if you are wearing too much. It is such a turn off to have a guy walk by and then get hit with his cologne for a minute after. It doesn't take much, in fact, if you apply it right before you go somewhere it is too much. Think about how close you want a girl to be when she smells it......two inches or across the parking lot.
Seriously, not just advice for the guys but some of us ladies tend to over do it too.
A subtle drift of aroma, not a knockdown typhoon of stink.